discrimin awar data mine dino pedreshi salvator ruggieri franco turini context civil right law discrimin refer unfair unequ treatment peopl base membership categori minor regard individu merit rule extract databas data mine techniqu classif associ rule decis task benefit credit approv discriminatori sens paper notion discriminatori classif rule introduc studi provid guarante discrimin shown trivial task naiv approach take discriminatori attribut shown background knowledg approach lead precis formul redlin problem formal result relat discriminatori rule appar safe mean background knowledg empir assess result german credit dataset provid 